Clashing Opinions on Test Equipment
Posted in Technology Stocks on December 6th, 2007In our roundtable discussion on semi-conductor test equipment this week, we had a significant differing of opinions. Patrick Ho of Stifel Nicolaus and Co. felt that test equipment companies are showing weakness, while Nikolay Tishchenko feels the current situation is a buying opportunity.
TWST: Patrick, What is going on from your perpective?
Mr. Ho: I think on a fundamental basis, there is clearly a greater level of cautiousness out there in the markets right now, particularly on the semiconductor side of things. With that being said, I am not surprised that the equipment stocks, particularly on the test side have also retreated, quite a bit actually, given that there is uncertainty in the marketplace…No one knows if the semiconductor companies are going to be exiting the year with excess inventory. That is why I think the test companies and even the equipment companies are showing a bit of weakness right now.
TWST: Nikolay, what is your take on the current inventory situation?
Dr. Tishchenko: I am not worried about inventories right now, but my opinion on the space is quite the opposite of Patrick’s. The reason is very simple. When I want to buy semiconductor capital equipment stocks, whether I am talking about front-end or back-end equipment stocks, I want good valuation. I want to use the times of uncertainty and I want to have some indirect indications of the trough in the demand for the equipment. I believe all of these pieces are now in place. To me, the current situation is a buying opportunity.
For the full roundtable, including a complete overview of the sector from these varying perspectives, and stock picks, click here.